Special Report: Unpaid City Fines - KCTV5

Special Report: Unpaid City Fines

Posted: Updated:
(Toledo News Now) -

It's time to pay up! 

Toledo Municipal Court is owed $23 million dollars in unpaid criminal and traffic fines. 

WTOL's Jenna Lee reviewed thousands of cases to find a wide variety of overdue balances.

The Clerk of Court told WTOL in an interview that the total amount due is shocking for a number of reasons. 

The Toledo Municipal Court primarily deals with criminal misdemeanors, such as, simple assault, petty theft and indecent exposure. It also handles the bulk of traffic offenses—speeding, drunk driving, driving without a license, etc. 

No matter what—criminal acts and traffic violations carry a steep cost. 

Once an offender's case closes, the individual receives a notice in the mail detailing an amount due. If he or she fails to pay the fine/fee within 30 days, the notice is then sent to a court-hired collection agency. 

Right now, Capital Recovery Services is trying to get a lot of money from a lot of people in Toledo. 

Currently, there are 3,006 active cases in the Toledo Municipal Court system, with unpaid fees exceeding $23 million dollars. 

"It's sad—I think it's really sad that people use the services of the court and don't pay up," said Vallie Bowman English, Toledo Municipal Clerk of Court. 

It's a large chunk of change that could help the city and state significantly, Bowman explains. When the fines are paid, the money is divided into several different categories benefitting: the courts, Toledo's General Fund (which is primarily dedicated to police, fire personnel and jail usage), the Crime Stoppers program and organizations to support victims of crimes. 

WTOL viewed the city of Toledo's approved 2014 budget. It allots a total of $4,805,350 to the Police Department and $7,485,121 for the Fire & Rescue Department. To put $23 million into perspective, if the city collected all of the money, it would be enough to pay for Toledo's entire police and fire departments for nearly two full years. http://toledo.oh.gov/media/104356/combined-book.pdf

Some of the unpaid fines date back decades; the oldest was issued in 1974! 

The names of criminals owing the most: 

Peter Cann—ordered to pay more than $10,000. 

Taylor Hudson—sentenced to fork over more than $6,000. 

James Hinckley—ruled to cough up more than $4,000. 

"It puts a strain on the entire system when the money is not received," said Bowman-English. 

It all comes down to finding the offenders—but that's not always easy. The Clerk of Court says the people could be anywhere in the world! 

To help recover the funds, a statewide "Warrant Block System" was implemented in 2003. The block denies the right to apply for a driver's license or vehicle registration to anyone with outstanding debt to the Clerk of Court's office. http://www.bmv.ohio.gov/warrant_block.stm

However, that measure did nothing to push Toledo lawbreakers stemming from 1974 to 2003 to shell out the cash. During that time period, Toledo Municipal Court actually had no system in place to pull in the money, attorneys served as collection agents and pocketed a third of the paid fine. 

"For cases that are prior to 2003, we can't put a warrant block on those cases. They are living in our jurisdiction, they're still registering their vehicle—they have no incentive to pay," said Bowman-English. 

With that said, the Clerk of Court is considering hiring an additional collection agency to recover the $23 million due. 

To view all 3,006 cases, click here.

To view the amount due by year, click here

Follow Toledo News Now:  

Mobile users, click on the "video" button in the app to watch this story. Download our app here.

Copyright 2014 Toledo News Now. All rights reserved.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Missouri man charged with felony after alleged racial slur

    Missouri man charged with felony after alleged racial slur

    Thursday, January 29 2015 11:44 PM EST2015-01-30 04:44:07 GMT
    A 65-year-old Maryville man is charged with felony assault after he allegedly confronted a black server as she served him breakfast. The man is accused of assaulting her and using racially insensitive language.More >
    A 65-year-old Maryville man is charged with felony assault after he allegedly confronted a black server as she served him breakfast. The man is accused of assaulting her and using racially insensitive language. More >
  • Surveillance video captures smash and grab at Independence home

    Surveillance video captures smash and grab at Independence home

    Thursday, May 25 2017 11:19 PM EDT2017-05-26 03:19:33 GMT
    Brian Graham faces burglary and theft charges, while David Sherrill is charged with burglary and receiving stolen property. (Submitted)Brian Graham faces burglary and theft charges, while David Sherrill is charged with burglary and receiving stolen property. (Submitted)

    Thieves smashed their way inside an Independence man's home as his crystal-clear surveillance cameras rolled.  

    More >

    Thieves smashed their way inside an Independence man's home as his crystal-clear surveillance cameras rolled.  

    More >
  • 2 shooting victims found in vehicle near 104th, Holmes

    2 shooting victims found in vehicle near 104th, Holmes

    Thursday, May 25 2017 6:14 PM EDT2017-05-25 22:14:44 GMT
    Chopper 5 video of the crime scene. (KCTV5)Chopper 5 video of the crime scene. (KCTV5)

    Police are investigating a double-shooting at 104th Street and Holmes.  One person is fighting for their life, while the second victim suffered serious but non-life threatening injuries.  This is the third double-shooting in Kansas City in the past 24 hours.  This is a developing story. Stay tuned to KCTV5 News for more. 

    More >

    Police are investigating a double-shooting at 104th Street and Holmes.  One person is fighting for their life, while the second victim suffered serious but non-life threatening injuries.  This is the third double-shooting in Kansas City in the past 24 hours.  This is a developing story. Stay tuned to KCTV5 News for more. 

    More >
Powered by Frankly
KCTV 5 News

Online Public File:
KCTV  KSMO

Powered by WorldNow CNN
All content © 2017, KCTV; Kansas City, MO. (A Meredith Corporation Station) . All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices.