Marilou Allen-Coogan says that throughout the different stages of the Jodi Arias trial, jurors were always respectful of one another, but, during deliberations, things got heated.
PHOENIX (CBS5) -
Before being chosen to sit on the jury for the Jodi Arias trial, Marilou Allen-Coogan described herself as sheltered.
"I've lived kind of an anonymous life," said Allen-Coogan.
The 52-year-old works as a nurse. When Allen-Coogan is not at the hospital, she is home with her family. But at the start of the year, all of that changed.
On television it seemed all anyone could talk about was Arias. But the jury didn't know the attention the case was getting.
"We did have an inkling and it was just that, an inkling," said Allen-Coogan.
Inside chambers, bonds formed fast.
"They were very independent, intelligent, thoughtful people on that jury. It surprised me how quickly we could all, all 18 of us form this incredible respect and friendship," said Allen-Coogan.
When it came time to start making decisions, Allen-Coogan said the process the jury used was incredibly methodical. She said throughout the different stages of the case, jurors were always respectful of one another; however, during deliberations, things did get heated many times.
In the end, the jury convicted Arias of first-degree murder. But when it came time to decide her punishment, the group couldn't come to a unanimous decision.
"Mitigating circumstances are very personal. It's not something that has to be proven by the defendant. It's something you feel based on you past, your conscience, your thought process and your heart that could warrant leniency and mercy," said Allen-Coogan.
Although Allen-Coogan voted for the death penalty, she said she respects the decisions of the four jurors who did not.
"I don't think anybody has the right to be angry with them or spew hatred on them because they voted their conscience," said Allen-Coogan.
Allen-Coogan said she prays another jury can be seated and that those individuals are as dedicated as the jury she sat on.
Copyright 2013 CBS 5 (KPHO Broadcasting Corporation). All rights reserved.
Arias juror No. 16 says she feels relieved, satisfiedMore>>
Thursday, April 17 2014 11:46 PM EDT2014-04-18 03:46:37 GMT
An ailing Miley Cyrus has canceled her concert Tuesday night at Sprint Center.The notice came a matter of hours before she was scheduled to go on stage.A concert promoter tells KCTV5 that Cyrus is in theMore >
An ailing Miley Cyrus remains in a Kansas City hospital and continues to cancel concerts. This comes after she unexpectedly canceled her KC concert.More >
Saturday, April 12 2014 6:07 AM EDT2014-04-12 10:07:09 GMT
An incredible photo snapped Saturday at the iconic Pipeline on Oahu's North Shore is going viral. A mother humpback whale and her calf were cruising just offshore when a set rolled in. J.T. Gray of NorthMore >
An incredible photo snapped Saturday at the iconic Pipeline on Oahu's North Shore is going viral.More >
Thursday, April 17 2014 4:43 PM EDT2014-04-17 20:43:50 GMT
Officials with the VA Medical Center in downtown Charleston say a North Charleston man who was initially federally charged with a $525 fine for an $.89 drink refill will instead be given a warning.More >
Officials with the VA Medical Center in downtown Charleston say a North Charleston man who was initially federally charged with a $525 fine for an $.89 drink refill will instead be given a warning. More >
Thursday, April 17 2014 10:33 PM EDT2014-04-18 02:33:26 GMT
Tears were shed and stories shared as hundreds gathered at a Kansas City church to remember the loving and giving life of Terri LaManno."My sister's life was one that we should all admire. Living a lifeMore >
Tears were shed and stories shared as hundreds gathered at a Kansas City church to remember the loving and giving life of Terri LaManno.More >
Thursday, April 17 2014 9:05 PM EDT2014-04-18 01:05:03 GMT
A Mount Tabor reservoir that holds Portland's drinking water has been taken offline out of fear that a group of trespassers urinated in it. Five people were seen at Mount Tabor Park around 1 a.m. Wednesday.More >
A Mount Tabor reservoir that holds Portland's drinking water has been taken offline after a teenager urinated in the reservoir. More >
Thursday, April 17 2014 11:14 PM EDT2014-04-18 03:14:53 GMT
Kansas City Police Chief Darryl Forte says they have the highway shooter suspect in custody. Police announced last week that they have positively linked 12 shooting incidents that have taken place onMore >
Kansas City police Chief Darryl Forte says they have the highway shooter suspect in custody. More >